Monday, 16 November 2026

Louder Than Words 2026

Due to having been almost constantly ill with a throat infection turned chest infection turned cold thing since late September, I was beginning to wonder by Saturday morning if I was going to make it to this years Louder Than Words fest at all.

I have taken to skipping the Friday evening events just because of working and living further away from Manchester than previously, but I don't think there were any events on the Friday this year that I really wanted to see.

As it was, I left home around 10am ish on Saturday morning and arrived at Innside just before 12 midday, meaning that I was in time for the annual Dancing About Architecture: Music Journalism panel discussion chaired by Dr Simon Morrison. The event takes its name from  Frank Zappa's famous quip that writing about music is like dancing about architecture. The event always feels like a nice start to Louder Than Words as it's a panel that bears repeating over the years just because the whole world of music journalism is in a constant state of flux and it's interesting to hear where concerns lie. This year it would be fair to say that the debate over working for free seems to have been largely replaced by the threat AI poses to music journalism and, indeed, the creative industries more generally and whether there are any helpful uses for AI in this world. As well as hearing people's experiences, and takes on these issues, it was also consoling to hear that Silent Radio is still going as I did look into possibly pitching to them at one point.

Alas, during the panel I had a monumental coughing fit which was resolved by one of the excellent Louder Than Words volunteers who very kindly offered to bring me a glass of water. She then brought me replacement glasses of water all the way through the panel discussion, for which I was exceedingly grateful.

After the panel discussion, I briefly spotted Helen McCookerybook by the loos, who introduced me to Molly Tie. Molly and I have twin interests in punk and riot grrrl and Helen had recommended a month or so ago that I talk to Molly about maybe extending/re-writing my punk etymology blog post and maybe pitching it to her. I'm not sure if I will or not at this stage as it's a piece I wrote because it felt necessary to but... I really, really enjoyed writing the one about how The Economist covered punk much, much more.*  We didn't chat for very long as Helen had to shoot off to play one of her mini sets but I knew I would see them both later in any case.

After this I nipped over to HOME to grab a takeaway mushroom and tarragon soup, which I ate by the statue of Engels on Jack Rosenthal Street. This is the statue I spotted last year, which has an explanation on a plaque next to it explaining its history. I wasn't really looking at it today though as I was too busy trying to make sure my takeaway box didn't blow away in the wind.

At 2:15pm I headed back inside for the Atypical Girls: Women and punk panel, chaired by John Robb. I think that this has been my favourite event of the weekend so far as the panel was made up of Helen McCookerybook, Penny Kiley and Molly Tie, three very different authors who have written three very different books about women and punk. Helen's The Lost Women of Rock Music is an academic text, an ethnographic social history, Penny Kiley's Atypical Girl is a memoir of her time in the Liverpool punk scene and as a music journalist, and Molly Tie's Rebel Grrrls is an exploration of punk and what it meant, and means, to women over a 50 year period, taking in multiple moments and scenes both here and in the US. The room was gratifyingly full and they explored a number of different themes and there was a lengthy chat about the importance of Vi Subversa and the Poison Girls as well as how the very nature of the music industry tends to destroy artists, despite the do-ability and accessibility of punk. 

We are in the 50th anniversary year of UK punk and, despite not really attending any anniversary themed events this year, I have been wondering if the events that have been put on have been as male dominated in personnel and focus as they were ten years ago. I think I might have seen some small signs of improvement, notably at Louder Than Words this weekend, but these are still baby steps insofar as acknowledging the importance of punk to women and girls and also the active part they played, and continue to play, in punk scenes around the world.

I had a lengthy conversation with the man next to me in the audience about this very topic, and other related ones. Toxic masculinity has been in the news a lot in the past few weeks and that, combined with some of the topics up for discussion this weekend, is perhaps making some men rather thoughtful. We had an interesting conversation which only really ended when it became increasingly clear that the volunteers needed to clear the room for the next event. I went downstairs and purchased the Molly Tie and Penny Kiley books after this (I already have Helen's) alongside the revised edition of Zoe Howe's Slits book.

After this I caught the very end of one of Helen's mini sets and stayed in the room to watch a wonderfully curmudgeonly Marco Pirroni being interviewed by John Robb. He explained to John that he was deaf in one ear as a result of a head cold, not due to rock'n'roll excess and noise abuse. I could sympathise. 

Helen met me afterwards and we went to HOME for a very late lunch/early tea.

I got back to Innside late to see Cathi Unsworth talking about her history of goth book, Season of the Witch. Coming in partway through seemed to throw me off a bit as I never really felt as though I was grasping the thread of it. It all felt quite intense but I did enjoy it and there was some great use of video to demonstrate the inspirational link between Siouxsie Sioux witnessing Julie Driscoll performing 'Wheels on fire' on Top of the Pops with Brian Auger, then Cathi Unsworth witnessing Siouxsie and the Banshees performing 'Spellbound' on Top of the Pops in 1981. 

After that I went back to the biggest room to watch Helen performing her full short set before Pauline Black. These are new songs about the Brighton punk scene from Helen's upcoming album, which will be themed around that.

At 8:15pm I went to the smallest of the four rooms to watch Sylvia Patterson being interviewed by Mark Hart about her new book I'm Not With The Man: A writer's life with the music mavericks. This is the follow up to her book I'm Not With The Band: A writer's life lost in music. The first book was more about her journey from Scotland to London and her career as a music journalists whereas the new book, while still drawing on interviews and encounters with musicians, is more intereview based and has at its heart the idea that something went horribly wrong with music and musicians in the 2000's, or certainly by 2019. The book is a salute to the mavericks of music past: The hellraisers, the troublemakers, the downright batshit crazy ones... and it comes with the acknowledgment that these are the people who have disappeared from modern day music. The 24/7 surveillance culture of internet led media is probably the main reason, though there may be others. I had wondered if a band like Fontaines DC would have been contenders for modern day maverick status but apparently not: Fontaines were ruled out as being too serious, too intense. Because Oasis and the Gallagher brothers were a regular topic of discussion I found myself sinking back into my own private 'What if' theory, namely that the Manchester music scene and, indeed, the global music scene would have been, and would have continued to be, a very different place had Puressence been the 1990s Manchester band to make it big, not Oasis. Failsworth rather than Burnage if you like, 'Near Distance' and 'I Suppose' rather than 'Wonderwall' and 'Cigarettes and Alcohol'. 

Sylvia was very lively and funny and she was well complemented by Mark, who had a relaxed style that worked very well. He had even visited the hotel shop (to his cost) to buy chocolate to offer as prizes to audience members if they answered questions right in his end of talk quiz. The audience was full of music journalists, who did very well out of the chocolate bonanza. 

After Sylvia's event I walked to Piccadilly and picked up a 192 quite quickly. Alas it must have been getting ahead of its timetable as it absolutely dawdled down the A6, stopping by McVities and in Merseyway for what felt like ages each time. This meant that I missed the 358 by about 5 minutes and was faced with a 30 minute wait at Stockport College for the next bus (the 383) at which point I admitted defeat and phoned a taxi to pick me up. I had considered just staying on the 192 and walking home from Hazel Grove but the 30 minute version of the walk home is dangerous enough in daylight and the 45 minute version involves going past a very eerie section of lay-by and fields that really gave me the willies the last time I did it.  I can feel a post for the Bus Chronicles coming on. Probably another rant directed at the Bee Network and TfGM on the theme of how those of us in Offerton, Marple, Compsall, Romiley, Bredbury, Marple Bridge, Hawk Green and Mellor should be allowed out without having to worry about how we're going to get home after 8pm. 

Getting home quite late on Saturday meant a late start on Sunday alas. I had planned to see Peter Wadsworth in conversation with Peter Tattersall talking about Strawberry Studios but I was still on the 192, probably somewhere around Levenshulme, when that talk started. I am comforting myself with the knowledge that the Stockport Music Story is keeping Strawberry alive and that I can pick up some of their activities locally anyway, but it was still a shame to miss it.

I didn't get to Jack Rosenthal Street until about 1pm so I opted for lunch at HOME, where there was a minor disagreement over how to say the word falafel (which I lost) but, aside from that, all went well. 

Helen McCookerybook was performing the final one of her mini sets in Room A not long after I arrived at Innside and, while there wasn't a lot of people in the audience, the set seemed to go down well with '1977' resonating particularly deeply with one of the volunteers, which bodes well for the albums release next year.

After Helen had finished I waited around in the room for a few minutes trying to decide whether to stay for Mike Pickering's dance related conversation with John Robb or whether to decant myself to Room D for In Search of Tito's Punks with Barry Phillips and Russ Bestley. In the end, I opted for Tito's punks and was very glad I had in the end. The story behind how Barry Phillips came to write what sounds like an incredibly eccentric book is multifaceted and somewhat epic in scale, but it was interesting, just as the central tale of how a song ('No room for you') by his late 70's/early 80's street punk band Demob (not to be confused with the mid/late 80s house music outfit D-Mob, who perpetuated the atrocity that was 'We Call It Aciiied' on an unsuspecting nation) came to be a punk anthem in Yugoslavia, translated, recorded and performed by countless bands across the nations that make up the former Yugoslavia. I will read this book I think at some point, but I didn't want to buy it today because I'd already bought three books yesterday and I know it will take me a while to get around to reading them. This event, while small, had the oldest and most noticeably male audience of the weekend I felt. Or at least when it came to events that I attended. 

By contrast, the final event of the day, Zoe Howe in conversation with Helen McCookerybook about her newly revised version of her first book. Typical Girls: The Story of The Slits, turned out to have both the youngest and the most noticeably female audience of the events I attended this weekend. It was also notable just how many audience members, again younger women, had purchased tickets to the event, not for the festival at large. As was widely acknowledged, a lot has changed for Zoe since the book was first published in 2009. Similarly, the Slits reputation has been enhanced by both Zoe's book but also Viv Albertine's book and the William Badgeley documentary Here To Be Heard. There is a sense now that there has been a shift in how the band are remembered and perceived. Small steps perhaps, but moving in the right direction. Zoe gave a number of readings from the book and I think that was a wise choice in terms of getting across the tone of the book and its unique voice. It's to be hoped that there will be a fresh resurgence of interest in both the book and The Slits. 

It was raining as I left and, while I was able to get on a 192 quite quickly (mainly by dodging traffic to get on one that was coming up to the stop) I had to wait around 20 minutes in the end for a 383 at Stockport College. At least I didn't have to weigh up the pros and cons of walking from Hazel Grove though - the wait was doable and the walk would have been even more horrible than usual in the rain.  

* Another reason for loving The Economist more generally is that about 15 years or so ago they ran an article in which they made the claim that Silvio Berlusconi was not fit to govern Italy. Berlusconi sued them... and lost. 

Thursday, 5 November 2026

Greetings From London


I’ve never been able to establish just how the Greetings From London postcard, with it’s customary picture of two mohicaned and sneering punks giving the two fingered salute, came about. I suspect that it evolved from the pictures tourists were taking of punks on the Kings Road in London and that this odd new phenomena was then taken advantage of by an enterprising entrepreneur with an interest in postcards.


Over the years, the images have changed, and the participants have - at times - leaned more towards goth than punk in image, but these postcards can still be found and purchased around the tourist shops in West London, 50 years after punks first flame.


Part of me wonders if they operate, at a British level at least, as a kind of follow on from the saucy seaside postcard of yore, and if they have become a kind of cheeky British institution. But part of me also wonders what on earth the average tourist is getting out of it when they purchase them. Is it that punk itself in the nations capital has become a key part of the tourist experience? 


I find them weirdly charming on a level I can’t quite fathom, and would miss them if they suddenly stopped existing.


The kind of images you see used for the postcards are posed and contrived but because they use ‘real’ punks and are taken on the streets, they have something in common with the work of the social documentary photographer Shirley Baker, who began her career producing unposed naturalistic photography around working class Salford and Manchester in the 1960s, but who did  - for a period in the 1980s - also take naturalistic photos of punks in Stockport (1981) and Camden (1986 through to 1991). What I like about Baker’s photos of the punks in Stockport is the way that her work echoes her earlier work from the 1950s and 1960s, where she also photographed young people in a naturalistic way at dances. 


Other naturalistic portraits of punk from the late 1970s and early 1980s would include the artist Jo Brocklehurst's drawings of her punk neighbours and Anita Corbin's photographic project Visual Girls, which depicted girls involved with a number of subcultures in the early to mid 1980s, including punk. 


Brocklehurst's portraits serve different functions to Baker’s social realism but, like Baker, Brocklehurst had no agenda - she just liked to draw interesting subjects and was well served in this regard by the punk squats in her neighbourhood of West Hampstead in the 1980s. 


Corbin’s two exhibitions had a more specific remit in that they were specifically about women and subculture, across multiple early 80s subcultures, including punk. This was a way to visually show the presence of women in subcultures, something often denied them.


Photo by Taylor Keeran on Unsplash

      

Tuesday, 20 October 2026

The death of BBC Radio 4Extra

When it was first announced in 2022 that the BBC was thinking of scrapping its digital only radio station 4Extra I was shocked and outraged enough to write the following piece for Medium.

Now that the decision is final and 4Extra will cease broadcasting in Spring 2027, I wanted to re-publish what I wrote then as I feel even more outraged and saddened four years on than I did then.

It's such a waste and the BBC clearly isn't going to realise what it's lost until it's far, far too late.

Anyone wanting to read more about 4Extra might want to check out the two posts I wrote in January early 2023 about the audacious experiment that was Jake Yapp's Unwinding. The first of which you can read here, and the second of which you can read here. We will never see it's like again. 

A Love Letter to BBC Radio 4Extra

The BBC launched its digital radio station BBC7, later 4Extra, in 2002. Now it plans to close it


When I first heard in late May that BBC Director General Tim Davie planned to scrap 4Extra, I was not exactly surprised (to my mind, the BBC have never really understood the popularity of the station) but I was very saddened. It all seemed so pointless.

The closure is part of a series of cuts over the next couple of years which are meant to make up for the deficit caused by the UK government freezing the BBC licence fee. But 4Extra only costs the corporation £3 million a year. Or, as a recent episode of Radio 4’s Feedback programme put it, “Two Gary Linekar’s”. Scrapping the station wouldn’t even touch the financial black hole the BBC finds itself in, so why do it?

Is the BBC’s relationship with the station akin to the one that ITV had with its ratings busting show Heartbeat? A show that was massively successful but in such a way (for its gentle, nostalgic characters and storylines), and with such an audience (older viewers) that the station was utterly embarrassed by it and ended up killing the show off?

There could be something in this, if only because 4Extra punches above its weight in terms of listeners (RAJAR figures for February 2022 report 4Extra’s listeners at 1.89million, more than Radio 1Xtra, which is not being threatened with the axe) and, yes, it is stereotyped as the station where pensioners go to listen to repeats of Hancocks Half Hour and The Goon Show.

But to stereotype 4Extra in this way is to underestimate the variety and breadth of its programming.

The station has, over the past twenty years, commissioned some exceptionally strong content, particularly Ben Moor’s Sci-Fi comedy Undone (3 series of this cult gem were commissioned by BBC7 and broadcast between 2006 and 2010) and Podcast Radio Hour (a long running review programme for podcasts).

The Comedy Club strand of programming, which broadcasts seven days a week between 10pm and midnight provides good late evening listening to contemporary and recent (ish) British radio comedies, as well as providing regular presenting shifts to the current crop of comedians. A gig that many, I suspect, appreciated during the past two years when Zoom gigs were their main source of income.

During the hell that was the 2019 Brexit negotiations, the station was a refuge for those who needed a break from shouty politics, thanks to its lack of news bulletins or current affairs programming.

In recent years, the station has provided a wider audience for harder to find programming, for example a recent broadcast of a fascinating documentary about the songwriters Roger Cook and Roger Greenaway, which was originally broadcast on BBC Radio Bristol in 2021. They’ve also broadcast content from the US’s NPR such as TED Radio Hour and The Moth Radio Hour, and podcasts such as Serial, which was broadcast on the station in 2014.

Because of its remit, 4Extra can dedicate long hours, weeks and months to themed broadcasting. This would include their broadcast of every episode of every series of The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy at 6:30pm, Monday-Friday, for months, with no break between series. It might not have been original content, but it’s a feat that needs saluting all the same.

On the subject of the stations Sci Fi content, it should also be pointed out that — for me — a key part of the stations appeal is its stranding pattern: You know that if you turn on between 6pm and 7pm it’s Sci Fi/Fantasy/Horror, 7pm — 8pm is vintage comedy, 8–9pm is crime and thrillers, and so on.

Some of the shows 4Extra introduced me to would include the aforementioned Undone, Andy Hamilton’s sitcom set in Hell Old Harry’s Game, the surreal opus that is The Brightonomicon, Dr Phil Hammond’s NHS GP satire Polyoaks, multiple Simon Brett comedies, the impeccable Natalie Haynes Stands Up For The Classics, the delightfully eccentric Big Science with Helen Keen, Noirish Roman gumshoe Falco, Medieval slueth Cadfael, the whimsically amusing The Blackburn Files, the moreish To Hull And Back, and 1980s cop drama Detective. Regardless of the schedule, it should also be said (and a recent contributor to Feedback mentioned this) that the station is an absolute godsend after midnight if you can’t sleep.

Critics will tell you that 4Extra is cosy, comfortable. Like a pair of slippers. But, as the commissioning of Undone and the audience sourced satire show Newsjack demonstrate, the station is also innovative. A case in point is its long running Friday night show Podcast Radio Hour. Just as, years ago, John Peels Radio 1 show made musical sense of Riot Grrrl for me, so Radio 4Extra was the station to demonstrate to me not only what a podcast was, but also why they were so popular. This was because it took the bold step of broadcasting the whole of series 1 of Serial on week nights over several weeks in 2014. When Podcast Radio Hour was launched not long after, I felt as though I’d been given the keys to the podcast cupboard: The show introduced me to the likes of Best Pick, Reasons To Be Cheerful, and We Are History.

I first began listening to 4Extra via the digibox/TV back when it was still BBC7 and I was still living at home. Often dad and I couldn’t find anything on TV to watch so we’d listen to some of the radio adaptations of novels, particularly Whiskey Galore and Cold Comfort Farm.

Once I’d left home I saved up to buy a digital radio so that I could listen to 6Music. But I found myself listening to 4Extra a lot more, especially on weekday evenings once I’d got in from work. I could cook to Hancocks Half Hour, Round The Horne, The Navy Lark or The Goon Show, all shows I’d heard on BBC cassettes years ago.

I purchased a portable digital radio a couple of years later in order to listen to The Comedy Club in bed. Once 4Extra is taken off the air, and is only available via BBC Sounds, I’ll have to fork out several hundred pounds for a smartphone in order to listen in bed. And that’s only going to be an option if 4Extra exists online in its current recognisable form, rather than being absorbed into BBC Sounds as non-structured ‘content’.

Judging from the volume of upset letters back in May to the Radio Times, and to the similarly large and upset volume of correspondence to last weeks episode of Feedback, I have come to the conclusion that I am very far from alone in my sense of sadness at the BBC’s decision to scrap the station.

What has made me angry has been the vagueness of the announcement, and the failure of Tim Davie to in any way defend or justify his decision to scrap the station. Is he hoping to whip up a storm that will see the station saved? This worked for 6Music and the Asian Network when they were under the axe. Or does he just not care? It could be that he expects the 4Extra audience to die off soon and, as such, suspects the outcry won’t last long. I hope that I am mistaken, but it doesn’t look good.

Monday, 5 October 2026

Lurid and ridiculous tabloid stories with a punk link, part 3: The Punk Princess


Princess Gloria Von Thurn Und Taxis kept the tabloids, broadsheets and society columns going for years in the late 1980s and early 1990s thanks to her punk past, outrageous outfits and haircuts, and her passion for motorbikes. Eccentric aristocracy always make good copy, and a punk princess who comes across as down to earth and not minding interacting with the press, seems to have cheered the press pack up after years of following Princess Diana about. Think of it as reporting on Steps for years then suddenly getting the brief to follow Lady Gaga and/or Charlotte Church on a night out in the early to mid noughties. 


How Gloria came to be The Punk Princess in the first place reads like something out of a Human League song: She was working [as a waitress?] in a cocktail bar… in Munich, not Sheffield, when “confirmed bachelor” Prince Johannes Baptista de Jesus Maria Louis Miguel Friedrich Bonfifazius Lommoral Furst Von Thurn und Taxis decided to marry her. She was 19, he was 53. Following their marriage, a profile piece by Dylan Jones in the Sunday Times from 1993 reveals, both parties pretty much carried on as they had when they were single: He apparently continued to “dally with young men” and she continued to ride motorbikes and hang out with rich types and popstars while wearing chain mail, mini skirts and designer leathers while sporting “baroque punk hairstyles”. 


After the death of her husband, Gloria put on the pearls and tweeds and put away the hair dye and motorbikes. This led to reports that she was trying to sort the estate out while not treating the servants well. 


In 2014 she was interviewed by Vanity Fair and it was revealed that her interests lay more in portraiture than punk. The piece also mentioned that she had close links to the Catholic Church and that she was a friend of Pope Benedict. The picture accompanying the piece showed her in glasses, sporting a huge egg neckace, while flanked by two leather clad bikers. 


Friday, 4 September 2026

Rotten Wood: A brief etymological history of punk


What do words really mean? Do they mean more than one thing? Where did they come from?

Such questions refer to etymology: The history and origins of words. 

My interest in the etymology of punk lies in my past as an English graduate. While researching and writing the initial series of essays that sewed the seed for the ongoing punk women book project, I was reminded of the fact that the word 'punk' had been in existence since Shakespeare's time, if not earlier. 

I was also still working at the university library at the time, and the floor I shelved on was mainly made up of Languages (the 400's), Literature (the 800's) and History (900s) books.* Meaning that I was in daily proximity to not just the language dictionaries, but also the etymological dictionaries; great big bulky things that explained the history of specific English words over the centuries.  

Study of these etymological dictionaries revealed that the earliest usage of the word punk dates back to 1596, although this excellent piece published on the British Library website has it slightly earlier at 'before 1575', from a ballad called 'Simon The Olde Kinge', at which point the word referred to a prostitute. Specifically, it was used to refer to women in Shakespeare’s Measure For Measure and in Jonson’s The Alchemist, two texts I studied for my degree. The word 'punkling', in use around the same time, refers to a young prostitute. 

The British Library piece mentioned above also found the word punk being used to refer to a young man being kept by an older man for sex as early as 1698, from a "bawdy song, 'Women's Complaint to Venus'."

Traditional ballads, which were sung, printed and distributed on the streets, were historical sources that I didn't have access to when writing this piece, but in retrospect it feels obvious that as sources they would be ahead of the game when it comes to changes in slang and language use over the centuries. 

So far as the Etymological dictionary research went, the next recorded use of the word punk is in the 18th century when it was used (mainly in the US) to describe a piece of rotten wood.

It's early in the history of the word but already we have three entirely separate meanings of the word that suggest someone, or something, is suspect. 

In the late nineteenth century there's a slight twist in etymological proceedings with the use of the phrase 'punk and plaster' being used by tramps to refer to bread and butter, which no doubt says much about the state of British bread baking at the time, as well as the British enthusiasm for butter. 

It's in the early twentieth century that the word punk becomes more codified to formally include the meaning 'passive male prostitute', often in a prison context, following on from it's earlier, seventeenth century usage to refer to a young man being kept by an older man for sex. It's also in the early twentieth century that we first encounter the word being used to refer to a 'worthless person'. It is these two particular set of meanings that are often quoted when the etymological origins of punk are being discussed, either because people haven't bothered to look any further back, or because it has suited the agendas of various punk writers over the years to go with this particular origin story: It being somewhat sexier to them than sixteenth century strumpets and harlots presumably. 

In order to try and hammer down the precise timeline for when the word punk starts to be used to refer to a particular style of music, I've had to go beyond etymological dictionaries and look as well at dictionaries and histories of music journalism. In terms of when the word punk was first used to describe music or subculture, the Oxford English dictionary says 1974 but this is a bit too late to be entirely accurate, and the British Library article agrees. 

If we’re taking into account journalists use of it to describe artists and scenes that didn’t end up being codified as punk in the recognised sound of 1976 sense, it goes back a few years earlier than that. Like me, the British Library article has homed in on the ? and the Mysterians song '96 Tears', which was released in 1966. As the British Library piece acknowledges, this song was retrospectively described as being punk by the US rock journalist Dave Marsh in 1971. The piece also points out that that the words 'punk music' were also used a year earlier, in 1970, on flyers to promote the minimalist electronic music of the band Suicide. 

As such, I would conclude that the use of the word punk to describe a particular musical and cultural moment in time that we would recognise historically as the punk scene probably starts around 1974 or 1975, but in terms of its use to describe music and musicians, it’s a few years before that. 

What's striking about the etymological history of punk is that, right from the start, the word was being used as a pejorative, a negative. Whether that be to refer to a woman or girl thought to be a prostitute, or to rotten wood, to suspect bread, to a man or a boy thought to be a prostitute, or to a generally worthless person. If it was punk, it was suspect, no good, worthless, terrible. And if you were a music writer in the late 1960s or early to mid 1970s and you saw music being made by some generally suspect youths, rougher than the normal rock'n'roll stars in waiting, it would perhaps be a natural leap to think of them as punks and the music they made as punk music. If there were rumours that some of the young, sexy, male musicians attached to those scenes did sell themselves for sex then all the better as that would fit a certain unspoken subcultural credo about rock'n'roll, male delinquency and male homosexuality. The earlier etymological history of punk could therefore be conveniently forgotten about.

That said, because the first known usage of the word punk is from either 'before 1575' or 1596, and at both points it was just another way of calling a woman or girl a strumpet, harlot or prostitute. This means that, if we look at the history of the word punk in a crushingly literal sense, the first punk was definitely a woman.

* It also contained Philosophy (100's) and Generalia (000's), the latter of which contained all the comix books and all the history of journalism books.

Photo by Brian Lundquist on Unsplash

Wednesday, 5 August 2026

Droll, disinterested and devastatingly incisive: How The Economist covered punk


During my 2014 journey through various newspaper databases I would occasionally come across reports by writers at The Economist. The quality and insight of these stories piqued my interest and led me to do a separate durational study on The Economist database for stories involving the word 'punk' for the years 1975-1995. 


While there were less results than in my wider search, those that I did find tended to be of a marked contrast to the stories I was reading in the Daily Mail and The Times. By contrast to the hysteria, The Economist tended to write about punk in a removed, faux disinterested, frequently droll, always devastatingly incisive way. 


As is often the case with that publication, their writers seemed to have a knack, at the height of public and press hysteria over punk, to cut through the bullshit and get to the heart of the matter. This is particularly evident in two stories they published about punk in the summer of 1977.


The first, titled ‘More money than music in nihilism’, concerns punk and the Silver Jubilee. The unnamed writer (The Economist doesn’t use bylines), sets out his or her stall quite early on, with the following:


Punk, or new-wave rock, gained notoriety when Mr Bill Grundy of Thames Television interviewed the Sex Pistols last year. The group so shocked the public (ie, delighted the press) and scared the record companies with its obscene language that it has already made £125,000 in broken recording contracts alone.


Now, correct me if I’m wrong, but, while they aren’t revealing anything readers probably didn’t already know here, the tone is striking. It suggests that both writer and publication are not prepared to join in with the moral panic around punk: they will comment on it, but they aren’t fooled by the machinations in the press and music industry that are fuelling it, and they don’t think their readers should be fooled either. 


Further on into the piece, the writer muses on what is meant to be shocking about punk, and concludes with the following shrewd observation:


This can be seen as just a re affirmation of rock music’s anti-establishment roots, which have been somewhat replaced over the past 10 years as the original working-class heroes have learned to enjoy the lifestyles of the rich.


Again, not imparting any new information here, but putting the point across in a delightfully low key snarky manner. They also aren’t fooled by the working class posturing of some of the punk fraternity either, reporting that while Mick Jones “once claimed that he had never lived below the 17th floor”, his bandmate Joe Strummer “went to a public school.”


The second of their pieces from the summer of 1977 is my personal favourite. It concerns the ongoing pitched battles between Teds and Punks on London’s Kings Road that summer, and is headed up ‘For an unlimited season, in Chelsea’. Full marks for droll understatement there.


In amongst the initial reportage of pitched battles on the Kings Road (or ‘Tribal warfare’ as the writer has it) are some interesting nuggets of information, including the observation that other people outside of the two tribes were being caught up in the violence, simply by virtue of being in the wrong place at the wrong time.


Last Saturday this meant a group of homosexuals who were protesting against the conviction of the editor of Gay News on a charge of blasphemous libel. 


As well as revealing in one stark sentence the extent to which the past is indeed a different country, I can’t imagine any other publication reporting on the Teds v Punks skirmishes including this particular detail.


The report goes on to describe the pitched battles as being “London’s latest tourist attraction” and points out that, as well as participants travelling from outside of London to be there, there were also some who’d travelled from outside of the country to be there as well, the report mentioning “continental” Teds and Punks. 


There then follows a thoughtful section on why the Teds and Punks have more in common than that which divides them, and the report concludes by offering some theories as to why it’s all kicking off in Chelsea in the first place. Their conclusion being that anti-hooligan strategies employed by the Metropolitan Police against Chelsea FC have led to violent elements gathering on or around the Kings Road instead, thus fuelling the violence. Not a popular conclusion, I suspect, when it came to fuelling the moral panic around punk, but I daresay there was something in it. 


While The Economist doesn’t report on punk per se in the 1980s, there is a thoughtful piece about the youth of Poland from summer 1982 (‘A lost generation’) that points out that, since the outlawing of Solidarity at the end of 1981, many of the country’s youth have turned away from politics and have embraced punk instead. 


Other mentions of punk throughout the 1980s and into the 1990s include referring to Colonel Qaddafi as “the Libyan punk” in 1981, some ruminating on punks fashion legacy in 1988, and a deliciously bitchy piece on Nigel Kennedy from 1991, following his dissing by the controller of Radio 3, John Drummond.


Mr Kennedy’s carefully cultivated cockney accent and extravagant clothes led Mr Drummond to accuse him of becoming the ‘Liberace of the nineties.’ 


Ouch. It’s like reading the 1990s equivalent of Bridgerton’s Lady Whistledown. 


Does any of this matter? In some ways yes, in some ways no. What The Economist coverage does, nearly fifty years after it was written, is provide a wider context to press coverage about the UK punk scene in those early years of hysteria and mayhem. The very nature of the coverage suggests that not everyone in the press was prepared to play along with the moral panic around punk, and that some intelligent mainstream press reportage and coverage was happening outside of punk. It’s important that intelligent and important questions were being asked, and that context was being provided. It’s easy to forget this when you look at the cultural narrative around punk, which tends to be written in black and white binary opposites.


Photo of London by Hugo Sousa on Unsplash