Due to having been almost constantly ill with a throat infection turned chest infection turned cold thing since late September, I was beginning to wonder by Saturday morning if I was going to make it to this years Louder Than Words fest at all.
I have taken to skipping the Friday evening events just because of working and living further away from Manchester than previously, but I don't think there were any events on the Friday this year that I really wanted to see.
As it was, I left home around 10am ish on Saturday morning and arrived at Innside just before 12 midday, meaning that I was in time for the annual Dancing About Architecture: Music Journalism panel discussion chaired by Dr Simon Morrison. The event takes its name from Frank Zappa's famous quip that writing about music is like dancing about architecture. The event always feels like a nice start to Louder Than Words as it's a panel that bears repeating over the years just because the whole world of music journalism is in a constant state of flux and it's interesting to hear where concerns lie. This year it would be fair to say that the debate over working for free seems to have been largely replaced by the threat AI poses to music journalism and, indeed, the creative industries more generally and whether there are any helpful uses for AI in this world. As well as hearing people's experiences, and takes on these issues, it was also consoling to hear that Silent Radio is still going as I did look into possibly pitching to them at one point.
Alas, during the panel I had a monumental coughing fit which was resolved by one of the excellent Louder Than Words volunteers who very kindly offered to bring me a glass of water. She then brought me replacement glasses of water all the way through the panel discussion, for which I was exceedingly grateful.
After the panel discussion, I briefly spotted Helen McCookerybook by the loos, who introduced me to Molly Tie. Molly and I have twin interests in punk and riot grrrl and Helen had recommended a month or so ago that I talk to Molly about maybe extending/re-writing my punk etymology blog post and maybe pitching it to her. I'm not sure if I will or not at this stage as it's a piece I wrote because it felt necessary to but... I really, really enjoyed writing the one about how The Economist covered punk much, much more.* We didn't chat for very long as Helen had to shoot off to play one of her mini sets but I knew I would see them both later in any case.
After this I nipped over to HOME to grab a takeaway mushroom and tarragon soup, which I ate by the statue of Engels on Jack Rosenthal Street. This is the statue I spotted last year, which has an explanation on a plaque next to it explaining its history. I wasn't really looking at it today though as I was too busy trying to make sure my takeaway box didn't blow away in the wind.
At 2:15pm I headed back inside for the Atypical Girls: Women and punk panel, chaired by John Robb. I think that this has been my favourite event of the weekend so far as the panel was made up of Helen McCookerybook, Penny Kiley and Molly Tie, three very different authors who have written three very different books about women and punk. Helen's The Lost Women of Rock Music is an academic text, an ethnographic social history, Penny Kiley's Atypical Girl is a memoir of her time in the Liverpool punk scene and as a music journalist, and Molly Tie's Rebel Grrrls is an exploration of punk and what it meant, and means, to women over a 50 year period, taking in multiple moments and scenes both here and in the US. The room was gratifyingly full and they explored a number of different themes and there was a lengthy chat about the importance of Vi Subversa and the Poison Girls as well as how the very nature of the music industry tends to destroy artists, despite the do-ability and accessibility of punk.
We are in the 50th anniversary year of UK punk and, despite not really attending any anniversary themed events this year, I have been wondering if the events that have been put on have been as male dominated in personnel and focus as they were ten years ago. I think I might have seen some small signs of improvement, notably at Louder Than Words this weekend, but these are still baby steps insofar as acknowledging the importance of punk to women and girls and also the active part they played, and continue to play, in punk scenes around the world.
I had a lengthy conversation with the man next to me in the audience about this very topic, and other related ones. Toxic masculinity has been in the news a lot in the past few weeks and that, combined with some of the topics up for discussion this weekend, is perhaps making some men rather thoughtful. We had an interesting conversation which only really ended when it became increasingly clear that the volunteers needed to clear the room for the next event. I went downstairs and purchased the Molly Tie and Penny Kiley books after this (I already have Helen's) alongside the revised edition of Zoe Howe's Slits book.
After this I caught the very end of one of Helen's mini sets and stayed in the room to watch a wonderfully curmudgeonly Marco Pirroni being interviewed by John Robb. He explained to John that he was deaf in one ear as a result of a head cold, not due to rock'n'roll excess and noise abuse. I could sympathise.
Helen met me afterwards and we went to HOME for a very late lunch/early tea.
I got back to Innside late to see Cathi Unsworth talking about her history of goth book, Season of the Witch. Coming in partway through seemed to throw me off a bit as I never really felt as though I was grasping the thread of it. It all felt quite intense but I did enjoy it and there was some great use of video to demonstrate the inspirational link between Siouxsie Sioux witnessing Julie Driscoll performing 'Wheels on fire' on Top of the Pops with Brian Auger, then Cathi Unsworth witnessing Siouxsie and the Banshees performing 'Spellbound' on Top of the Pops in 1981.
After that I went back to the biggest room to watch Helen performing her full short set before Pauline Black. These are new songs about the Brighton punk scene from Helen's upcoming album, which will be themed around that.
At 8:15pm I went to the smallest of the four rooms to watch Sylvia Patterson being interviewed by Mark Hart about her new book I'm Not With The Man: A writer's life with the music mavericks. This is the follow up to her book I'm Not With The Band: A writer's life lost in music. The first book was more about her journey from Scotland to London and her career as a music journalists whereas the new book, while still drawing on interviews and encounters with musicians, is more intereview based and has at its heart the idea that something went horribly wrong with music and musicians in the 2000's, or certainly by 2019. The book is a salute to the mavericks of music past: The hellraisers, the troublemakers, the downright batshit crazy ones... and it comes with the acknowledgment that these are the people who have disappeared from modern day music. The 24/7 surveillance culture of internet led media is probably the main reason, though there may be others. I had wondered if a band like Fontaines DC would have been contenders for modern day maverick status but apparently not: Fontaines were ruled out as being too serious, too intense. Because Oasis and the Gallagher brothers were a regular topic of discussion I found myself sinking back into my own private 'What if' theory, namely that the Manchester music scene and, indeed, the global music scene would have been, and would have continued to be, a very different place had Puressence been the 1990s Manchester band to make it big, not Oasis. Failsworth rather than Burnage if you like, 'Near Distance' and 'I Suppose' rather than 'Wonderwall' and 'Cigarettes and Alcohol'.
Sylvia was very lively and funny and she was well complemented by Mark, who had a relaxed style that worked very well. He had even visited the hotel shop (to his cost) to buy chocolate to offer as prizes to audience members if they answered questions right in his end of talk quiz. The audience was full of music journalists, who did very well out of the chocolate bonanza.
After Sylvia's event I walked to Piccadilly and picked up a 192 quite quickly. Alas it must have been getting ahead of its timetable as it absolutely dawdled down the A6, stopping by McVities and in Merseyway for what felt like ages each time. This meant that I missed the 358 by about 5 minutes and was faced with a 30 minute wait at Stockport College for the next bus (the 383) at which point I admitted defeat and phoned a taxi to pick me up. I had considered just staying on the 192 and walking home from Hazel Grove but the 30 minute version of the walk home is dangerous enough in daylight and the 45 minute version involves going past a very eerie section of lay-by and fields that really gave me the willies the last time I did it. I can feel a post for the Bus Chronicles coming on. Probably another rant directed at the Bee Network and TfGM on the theme of how those of us in Offerton, Marple, Compsall, Romiley, Bredbury, Marple Bridge, Hawk Green and Mellor should be allowed out without having to worry about how we're going to get home after 8pm.
Getting home quite late on Saturday meant a late start on Sunday alas. I had planned to see Peter Wadsworth in conversation with Peter Tattersall talking about Strawberry Studios but I was still on the 192, probably somewhere around Levenshulme, when that talk started. I am comforting myself with the knowledge that the Stockport Music Story is keeping Strawberry alive and that I can pick up some of their activities locally anyway, but it was still a shame to miss it.
I didn't get to Jack Rosenthal Street until about 1pm so I opted for lunch at HOME, where there was a minor disagreement over how to say the word falafel (which I lost) but, aside from that, all went well.
Helen McCookerybook was performing the final one of her mini sets in Room A not long after I arrived at Innside and, while there wasn't a lot of people in the audience, the set seemed to go down well with '1977' resonating particularly deeply with one of the volunteers, which bodes well for the albums release next year.
After Helen had finished I waited around in the room for a few minutes trying to decide whether to stay for Mike Pickering's dance related conversation with John Robb or whether to decant myself to Room D for In Search of Tito's Punks with Barry Phillips and Russ Bestley. In the end, I opted for Tito's punks and was very glad I had in the end. The story behind how Barry Phillips came to write what sounds like an incredibly eccentric book is multifaceted and somewhat epic in scale, but it was interesting, just as the central tale of how a song ('No room for you') by his late 70's/early 80's street punk band Demob (not to be confused with the mid/late 80s house music outfit D-Mob, who perpetuated the atrocity that was 'We Call It Aciiied' on an unsuspecting nation) came to be a punk anthem in Yugoslavia, translated, recorded and performed by countless bands across the nations that make up the former Yugoslavia. I will read this book I think at some point, but I didn't want to buy it today because I'd already bought three books yesterday and I know it will take me a while to get around to reading them. This event, while small, had the oldest and most noticeably male audience of the weekend I felt. Or at least when it came to events that I attended.
By contrast, the final event of the day, Zoe Howe in conversation with Helen McCookerybook about her newly revised version of her first book. Typical Girls: The Story of The Slits, turned out to have both the youngest and the most noticeably female audience of the events I attended this weekend. It was also notable just how many audience members, again younger women, had purchased tickets to the event, not for the festival at large. As was widely acknowledged, a lot has changed for Zoe since the book was first published in 2009. Similarly, the Slits reputation has been enhanced by both Zoe's book but also Viv Albertine's book and the William Badgeley documentary Here To Be Heard. There is a sense now that there has been a shift in how the band are remembered and perceived. Small steps perhaps, but moving in the right direction. Zoe gave a number of readings from the book and I think that was a wise choice in terms of getting across the tone of the book and its unique voice. It's to be hoped that there will be a fresh resurgence of interest in both the book and The Slits.
It was raining as I left and, while I was able to get on a 192 quite quickly (mainly by dodging traffic to get on one that was coming up to the stop) I had to wait around 20 minutes in the end for a 383 at Stockport College. At least I didn't have to weigh up the pros and cons of walking from Hazel Grove though - the wait was doable and the walk would have been even more horrible than usual in the rain.
* Another reason for loving The Economist more generally is that about 15 years or so ago they ran an article in which they made the claim that Silvio Berlusconi was not fit to govern Italy. Berlusconi sued them... and lost.







